All-Winners Comic Book Price Guide

Timely // Summer 1941 - Winter 1946-47
Issue count: 20

Not really a "team" book, Timely did offer some more obscure heroes in All-Winners in addition to their proven faves.We got BLACK MARVEL, THE DESTROYER, THE WHIZZER, & MISS LIBERTY! These are vault-worthy books if you got 'em! .

All Winners Comics

Timely’s All-Winner Comics was introduced as a 68-page giant Quarterly in the Summer of 1941, following suit with National/DC who had just started putting their best selling characters in giant-sized quarterlies.

The difference between the DC titles and this Timely title, was that DC’s books in this format tended to feature stories all with the same character - for example : their quarterly Green Lantern title gave us a whole 52 - 62 pages of JUST Green Lantern stories, he was otherwise included as the lead story in All-American Comics plus co-features including other heroes. Now, for Timely, the idea was to put 1 story each of their most popular superheroes, and pad it out by introducing new characters, or give more time to ones that had been neglected in their other regular sized books.

The WWII - Era was a boom-time for Timely/Marvel, their heroes were already fighting nazis BEFORE America entered the war - they had successfully predicted where things were headed, and had a staff that was very passionate and outspoken about being against the Axis advance.

Timely’s big three best sellers were Captain America, The Human Torch, and The Sub-Mariner, and indeed these were the heroes most prominently featured in All-Winners Comics. The first two issues felt like the book was finding it’s footing, featuring The Black Marvel, a character that never really caught on, and The Angel, Paul Gustavson’s hero that was already pretty popular in Marvel Mystery Comics, but is rarely referenced today.

With issue #3, All-Winners started to hit a comfortable stride, adding The Whizzer and The Destroyer as backup stories in addition to the big three. Notable within the next few issues, was the addition of a young Mickey Spillane to the writing staff (Spillane, of course, would go on to pulp-detective fame and fortune with a prolific string of novels featuring his famous creation, Mike Hammer!). Spillane scripted The Human Torch story in issue #3 and in #6, in addition to a couple of 2 page text stories as filler along the way.

As with their other quarterly, All-Select Comics, issues #7 through #18 featured the fantastically dynamic cover art of master Alex Schomburg, making these worth the cover price alone (still 10 cents! A bargain!)!

Paper and labor shortage reduced the book to a more standard 36 pages for issues #14 through #16, in which issues Timely jettisoned the Human Torch story (during this same period, All-Select did away with their Sub-Mariner story).

Things returned to “normal” with issue #17. Going back to the 52 to 68 page format, and reinstating the Torch story. Funny thing is, though, that in the meantime, America had dropped “The Big One,” and just-like-that, it seemed like there was nobody left to fight. This was Winter 1945-1946, and the beginning of the downward trend in the popularity of the superhero craze of the so-called “Golden-Age.”

All-Winners pressed-on for two more issues with a new format ; the (oddly numbered) issues #19 and #21, added Miss America to the fold, and our regular cast started fighting alongside in one continuing storyline as a super team dubbed The All-Winners Squad (DC had had this idea well sewn-up with All-Star Comics and The Justice League of America for several years now). A good idea whose time had unfortunately passed Timely by.

All 20 issues are not seen much nowadays on the market, but when they pop-up the often fetch unbelievable prices! Use Quality Comix’s online price guide and check ‘em out! Sell your rare comics to us - we offer free appraisals on all comics.

Read More

Looking to sell your comic books?

Browse our selection of key issues from All-Winners Comic Book Price Guide below to get an instant estimate of their value.

We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!

Get Your Free Appraisal

Key Art: Comic Book Price Guide

Issue #1

What's All Winners Comics #1 worth in 2021?

The current value of All Winners Comics #1 in Mint condition is about $100,000.  A CGC NM+ 9.6 last sold for $50,000 in 2011.  If you're looking for a copy, pick one up in low grade, where the best price appreciation is.  Copies have doubled in value from $1,500 to $3,000 in GD 2.0 in the past 10 years or so.

Why is this comic book valuable?

All Winners Comics #1 was published in 1941 by Timely Comics and featured separate stories of the Human Torch, Sub-Mariner, Captain America, and a few other minor super-heroes.  These 3 main heroes eventually teamed up with the Whizzer and Miss America in issue #19 to form the All-Winners Squad in 1946.  The All Winners Squad was introduced in #1 in text form.

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$2,000 $4,000 $8,000 $16,000 $48,000 $95,200

Sell All Winners Comics #1

Issue #2

What's All Winners Comics #2 worth in 2021?

A single NM 9.4 is the top grade available for this issue, selling for $24,500 in 2017. Below this grade is a single NM- 9.2, and another single VF/NM 9.0. With only 39 registered copies of the book, sales data for the mid-to-low end is hard to come by. A VG 4.0 showed some modest growth, climbing from $900 in 2003 to its current value of $1,500. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

It's the first appearance of Colonel Carter, a military ally to Captain America and Bucky. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$700 $1,500 $2,800 $4,925 $18,500 $24,500

Sell All Winners Comics #2

Issue #3

What's All Winners Comics #3 worth in 2021?

One copy of a NM+ 9.6 is the highest grade on record for this issue, selling for a top price of $6,900 in 2003. Grades below this have generally shown flat growth, but some proved to be good investments. If you bought a VG+ in 2008 for $650, you'd be looking at an increase to $1,675 for its current value. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The first and only appearance of WWII era Japanese villains Micka and the Black Dragon Society.

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$800 $1,300 $2,100 $3,400 $10,500 $6,900

Sell All Winners Comics #3

Issue #4

What's All Winners Comics #4 worth in 2021?

A NM- 9.2 of this issue sold for $9,200 in 2014. A VG 4.0 has shown a slow but steady increase in value over time, climbing from a sell price of $700 to today's $2,000. That's a profit of nearly 200%! Similarly, a VG/FN in that sold for $1,150 in 2003 is now worth $2,500. The mid and low ranges have very little sales data to look at due to the issue's limited 43 registered copies.

Why is this comic book valuable?

The Human Torch takes on WWII era Japanese villain Moppino. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$1,000 $2,050 $3,500 $6,500 $17,500 $9,200

Sell All Winners Comics #4

Issue #5

What's All Winners Comics #5 worth in 2021?

The only registered NM- 9.2 for this issue sold for $4,255. There is one book graded above it at NM 9.4, but no sales data exists for it. There is very little sales history for this issue at other grades, given the limited quantity of 43 registered copies. The information available shows flat growth, though a VG 4.0 sold in 2013 for $525 is now worth $670. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of Nazi villain Captain von Spitz, a terrorist looking to cause death and destruction in New York City. Human Torch comes to the rescue. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$450 $1,050 $1,600 $3,200 $9,000 $4,250

Sell All Winners Comics #5

Issue #6

What's All Winners Comics #6 worth in 2021?

There are two copies of this book registered at the highest available grade of VF/NM 9.0. Neither has any sales data available, giving a single VF+ 8.5 the record high price of $14,340 in 2015. A VG 3.0 of this book doubled in price within a short timeframe, increasing from a value of $500 in $2014 to today's $1,075. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of Big Eyes, a villainous and violent mobster who prints counterfeit money. His operation is stopped by the Human Torch. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$1,075 $1,750 $3,725 $9,650 $30,000 $14,350

Sell All Winners Comics #6

Issue #7

What's All Winners Comics #7 worth in 2021?

The top price for this book was $2,868 for a FN 6.0 in 2014. Talk about a unique market for this one: there are four books above this grade! A FN/VF 7.0 sold for $2,032 in 2014. The other grades have no sales data, ranging from VF- 7.5 to NM 9.4! A VG 4.0 doubled in price from $600 in 2012 to its current value of $1,200. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of Nazi villain Joe Grupper, who runs an operation poisoning the food of American troops. The Human Torch saves the day. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$700 $1,500 $2,700 $4,500 $14,200 $2,875

Sell All Winners Comics #7

Issue #8

What's All Winners Comics #8 worth in 2021?

The highest sale price on record for this issue is $3,910 for a VF 8.0 in 2011. Two higher grades exist at VF+ 8.5 and VF/NM 9.0, but there is no sales data on file for either. If you picked up a VG/FN 5.0 copy of this issue in 2003 for $600, you'd be looking at a jump to today's price of $2,400. That's a profit of 400%!

Why is this comic book valuable?

Adolf Hitler and Herman Goering are depicted releasing the insane (and fictional) Herr Blutcher to take out the Human Torch. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$410 $900 $1,800 $3,900 $13,000 $3,900

Sell All Winners Comics #8

Issue #9

What's All Winners Comics #9 worth in 2021?

No sales data exists for the highest grade on file for this issue: a single NM 9.4. The next grade down consists of three books at VF+ 8.5, with a record price of $4,250 in 2011. Low-to-mid grades have seen very little growth, though a FN 6.0 that sold for $1,150 in 2005 provided a small profit with today's value of $1,650 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of Bashon, a mad scientist who uses planes and tanks to wreak havoc. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$400 $800 $1,650 $3,000 $10,000 $4,250

Sell All Winners Comics #9

Issue #10

What's All Winners Comics #10 worth in 2021?

The highest sale on record for this issue was $2,868 for a VF 8.0 in 2015. There are five registered copies at this grade. A FN/NM 9.0 sold for a lesser price of $2,760 back in 2002. The top grade for this issue is a NM- 9.2, but it has no sales data available. Other grades show flat upward movement, though a FN 6.0 jumped from $1,275 in 2005 to today's value of $1,770. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of The Vulture. No, not the Spidey villain! This one was named Harrison Klein, and he used birds as weapons of destruction. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$600 $1,200 $2,000 $3,200 $10,400 $2,868

Sell All Winners Comics #10

Issue #11

What's All Winners Comics #11 worth in 2021?

Here's an issue with a serious outlier: in 2018, a FN+ 6.5 sold for $4,063! There are two copies available at this grade, and ten above it. The second highest value was $1,800 for a FN/VF 7.0 in 2016. Weird stuff. A VG 4.0 produced over a 300% increase in value from $500 in 2004 to today's $1,700

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of The Hawk, a Nazi villain who caused damage with stolen airships before he was stopped by the Human Torch. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$800 $1,700 $3,000 $5,000 $14,000 $4,075

Sell All Winners Comics #11

Issue #12

What's All Winners Comics #12 worth in 2021?

The highest graded copy of this book is a single NM 9.4, and it sold for $20,650. The previous owner must be quite happy with his nearly $10,000 in profit after picking it up for $11,500 in 2011! You'd also be thrilled with your 400% increase in value if you bought a FN/VF for $1,000 in 2002. It's now worth $4,000!

Why is this comic book valuable?

The only appearance of The Wisp, a Nazi spy disguised as an elderly woman. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$800 $1,600 $2,500 $4,800 $13,800 $20,650

Sell All Winners Comics #12

Issue #13

What's All Winners Comics #13 worth in 2021?

Three copies of this issue exist at VF+ 8.5, with a top sales price of $3,346. A single NM 9.4 exists above it, but there's no sales data on file for this top grade. Other grades have shown very little growth, other than FN+ 6.5. It's nearly doubled in price from $525 in 2002 to today's $1,100

Why is this comic book valuable?

The first and only appearance of Madame X. This villain took the form of a man disguised as a woman within America. "She" infiltrated factories to steal military plans for the Nazis. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$600 $1,125 $1,500 $3,000 $9,000 $3,350

Sell All Winners Comics #13

Issue #14

What's All Winners Comics #14 worth in 2021?

There are two books on file graded at 9.4, with a top sales price of $5,900. This beats the value of the highest grade: a single NM+ 9.6 that sold for $5,558. That was back in 2002, which would account for the small difference. There is little data available for other grades, though FN+ 6.5 doubled in price from $500 in 2002 to today's $1,000.

Why is this comic book valuable?

Sub-Mariner uses his powers to stop a gang of mobsters who stole precious gems. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$370 $700 $1,200 $2,100 $6,400 $5,900

Sell All Winners Comics #14

Issue #15

What's All Winners Comics #15 worth in 2021?

Three books are registered at VF/NM 9.0, with a top price of $3,400 in 2013. One NM- 9.4 exists above it, but has no sales history available. Other grades have shown slow but positive growth: FN- 5.5 from $550 in 2005 to today's $825, and GD/VG for $425 in 2012 to its current value of $750. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The villainous Mr. White kills inventor Roy Winters, a friend of Sub-Mariner. Namor discovers the plot and brings Mr. White to justice. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$500 $900 $1,500 $2,500 $7,000 $3,400

Sell All Winners Comics #15

Issue #16

What's All Winners Comics #16 worth in 2021?

This issue has three registered copies at NM- 9.2, with a top price of $3,000 in 2006. There's one NM 9.4 above it without any sales history. If you had the patience to hold onto a VG/FN purchased for $400 in 2005, you've been rewarded. It now goes for $1,450, a profit over 300%! 

Why is this comic book valuable?

Sub-Mariner's friend Ed Jordan is killed when his surfboard explodes. Namor takes the investigation into his own hands and finds the perpetrator. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$250 $600 $1,400 $2,500 $7,000 $3,000

Sell All Winners Comics #16

Issue #17

What's All Winners Comics #17 worth in 2021?

The top grade on file for this book is NM 9.4, but it has no sales history on file. The next grade down is a single NM- 9.2, which sold for $4,183 in 2010. Little sales data exists for this issue, with only 36 registered copies available. Many have shown massive up-and-down fluctuations. The VG/FN 5.0 has the best growth, increasing in value from $350 in 2003 to today's $950. 

Why is this comic book valuable?

The first and only appearance of the villain Black Phantom. 

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$400 $800 $1,200 $2,000 $5,500 $4,175

Sell All Winners Comics #17

Issue #18

What's All Winners Comics #18 worth in 2021?

The highest grade for this issue is a NM+ 9.6, which sold for $4,780 in 2014. #18 only has 30 registered copies, so sales data is sparse. The two grades with multiple sales have shown solid growth; a FN- 5.5 valued at $450 is now $1,300, and VF- 7.5 provided a 250% profit between $600 in 2002 to today's $2,100

Why is this comic book valuable?

Sub-Mariner saves Betty Dean from a kidnapping by a group of thugs, and finds their stash of stolen money too!

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$350 $675 $1,300 $2,200 $6,000 $4,775

Sell All Winners Comics #18

Issue #19

What's All Winners Comics #19 worth in 2021?

The mint condition value of All-Winners Comics #19 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 9.0 that sold for the price of $8,625 in August 2005. An unretouched 8.5 has a July 2011 value of $12,500, and an unretouched 7.0 sold for the price of $4,857 in June 2019, which is a decrease from its peak June 2010 value of $6,000.

Why is this comic book valuable?

The first appearance and origin of the All-Winners Squad occur in All-Winners Comics #19, published in Fall 1946 by Timely Comics. Superheros ranging from Captain America to Human Torch to Sub-Mariner to Miss America team up to take on a crafty villain.

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$1,000 $2,100 $4,000 $8,000 $22,000 $12,500

Sell All Winners Comics #19

Issue #21

What's All Winners Comics #21 worth in 2021?

The mint condition value of All-Winners Comics #21 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 8.5 that sold for the price of $3,600 in April 2019. An unretouched 7.0 has an August 2019 value of $4,800, which is an increase from its July 2018 price of $3,027 but a decrease from its peak August 2015 value of $5,019.

Why is this comic book valuable?

All-Winners Comics #21 is the final issue of the series, and was published by Timely Comics in Winter 1946. Cap calls the Squad together to team up against Future Man. Future Man has returned from the 20th Century, and with the help of Madame Death, he plans to wipe out mankind.

Price Guide Report

GD 2.0 VG 4.0 FN 6.0 VF 8.0 NM 9.4 RECORD SALE!
$800 $1,500 $3,000 $5,975 $16,000 $72,000

Sell All Winners Comics #21