Disclaimer:
When you click on link title "Check Live eBay Prices Here" on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include the eBay Partner Network. Check our Privacy Policy for more information.
Mystic
Atlas // March 1951 - August 1957
Issue count: 61
Another pre-Marvel Atlas Comics supernatural/horror/suspense title that preceded the Marvel favorites of the late 50's-early 60's. In many cases, Mystic used the same writers and artists that would find acclaim years later! See current prices here...
It took a little bit of time for Atlas Comics (formerly Timely Comics) to find their footing in the 1950’s as far as the creative direction in which they wanted the company to go.
Martin Goodman’s Timely Comics had, by 1949, ceased publication of almost all of it’s superhero books that had brought it such good fortune from 1939 through the end of the Second World War. Captain America, the Human Torch and The Sub-Mariner were fading from public consciousness, and the whole comic book business was turned on its head; it seems America did not need heroes in their comics, they had them in their homes in the men and women that had come back after the big war…
One may think that tastes would have veered towards the more fanciful, for the country had had enough of the death and dying. But no - the flavor of the day was moving towards the darker subjects of everyday criminals, monsters, and unexplained phenomenon. Perhaps this turnabout in content could be explained as simply being a reflection of the collective national fatigue of war, and the uncertainty and paranoia of facing a future in a post-atomic-bomb world.
Monsters of unexplained origin, scenarios of invasions from alien beings resonated more as the threat of global communist-domination was repeatedly heralded in the daily news.
Atlas debuted their title Mystic in the Spring of 1951, and can pretty-much be considered the “sister” book of Atlas’ Mystery Tales, which came out almost exactly a year later.
Similar themes and images to Mystery Tales are explored on the covers of Mystic - monsters, murders, the undead, ghosts that can’t find peace, live burial, a mysterious pair of gloves that come to life, dungeon bondage, Russian zombie-soldiers, a skeleton bride and groom, dead people discovered in freezers, a human face ripped open only to reveal a hideous monster underneath, ghouls serving a decapitated head for supper, cocktails with shrunken dead men floating in them, aliens popping out of television screens, ghosts emerging from manholes and drains as an unsuspecting police officer walks his night beat…
The book ran for over six years (ceasing production in the Fall of 1957), and was a key prototype of the kind of books that Atlas - under its new name Marvel Comics - would be producing very soon. In fact, many of the same creatives that were involved in Mystic would go on to find lots of work at Marvel in the 60s and beyond. Of course, Stan Lee both edited the book and contributed stories. Among the artists responsible for many stories were Gene Colan, Dick Ayers, George Roussos (aka George Bell), Joe Sinnott, John Romita , Bill Everett, George Tuska, Gil Kane, Bob Powell, Ross Andru, Vince Colletta,Jim Mooney, Werner Roth, Jack Abel, Don Heck, Bob Brown and John Severin. These names will forever be associated with Marvel.
Mystic remains a very obscure Atlas title, making its 61 issues very collectible. Check out some of the going rates on Quality Comix’s online price guide!
Looking to sell your comic books?
Browse our selection of key issues from Mystic below to get an instant estimate of their value.
We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!
Issue #1
What's Mystic #1 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #1 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 9.0 that sold for the price of $2,495. That May 2018 value is an increase from its December 2009 value of $960. An unretouched 8.5 has a July 2019 value of $1,300.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man travels forward in time in Mystic #1, published by Atlas Comics in March 1951. A man discovers that dinosaurs have returned to the planet after humanity killed itself through nuclear war. A reporter goes in search of a missing man, just to discover he was killed at the hands of his own robot.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $150 | $300 | $600 | $1,200 | $4,800 | $2,495 |
Issue #2
What's Mystic #2 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #2 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an 8.0 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $507 in April 2012. An unretouched 8.0 has a December 2011 value of $418, and an unretouched 7.5 sold for the price of $304 in February 2017, which is a decrease from its May 2013 value of $441 but an increase from its April 2003 value of $144.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A sweet woman befriends an ugly man in Mystic #2, published in May 1951 by Atlas Comics. Otto loves her and works as her servant, vowing to protect her from evil. The tailor is a brutish man who will do anything to 'win' her, and kills Otto in order to get to her. He forces the girl to marry him by keeping her prisoner in her home, and she cheers herself up by creating clothes for the tailor's dummy and naming it after her beloved servant. One day, the tailor begins to beat her, and Otto the dummy rises and strangles him to death.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $70 | $140 | $275 | $550 | $2,200 | $507 |
Issue #3
What's Mystic #3 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #3 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 9.0 from the Davis Crippen pedigree that sold for the price of $1,205. That October 2015 value is an increase from its September 2006 price of $388. An unretouched 5.0 has a value of $125 as of September 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A text story and illustration by Russ Heath is featured in Mystic #3, published by Atlas Comics in July 1951. A man learns a hard lesson about playing God in The Undead. Alice has been dead for many years when Anthony reanimates his wifes corpse. However, he is repulsed when she is a rotting corpse instead of the beauty from his memory.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $110 | $225 | $450 | $1,800 | $1,205 |
Issue #4
What's Mystic #4 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #4 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $518 in June 2004. An unretouched 7.5 has a December 2013 value of $1,050, and an unretouched 5.0 sold for the price of $384 in February 2020.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A couple finds themselves deep in the den of the Devil-Bird in Mystic #4, published in September 1951 by Atlas Comics. A man and his lady love Gloria slip on the edge of the mountain, and Gloria begins to lose her grip when she comes eye-to-eye with the Devil-Bird who lives there.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $110 | $225 | $450 | $900 | $3,600 | $1,050 |
Issue #5
What's Mystic #5 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #5 is $2,300. This value is based on the highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction, which is a 9.4 NM from the River City pedigree that sold in May 2018. An unretouched 7.5 has an August 2004 value of $1,300, and an unretouched 4.5 sold for the price of $140 in March 2020.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Entire cities are disappearing in Mystic #5, published by Atlas Comics in November 1951. Towns all over the world are being pulled into space by hostile aliens using a giant magnet. The people of Earth load up the next city with bombs, setting them to go off when the city is pulled to its target.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $110 | $220 | $425 | $1,600 | $2,300 |
Issue #6
What's Mystic #6 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #6 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $403 in November 2003. An unretouched 7.5 has a November 2014 value of $598, and an unretouched 7.0 sold for the price of $432 in October 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A scientist creates a time machine in Mystic #6, published in January 1952 by Atlas Comics. A great inventor creates the machine that travels through time, but when he travels to the future, he is horrified. He witnesses the after-effects of Earth's atomic war, and commits suicide.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $80 | $160 | $325 | $650 | $2,600 | $598 |
Issue #7
What's Mystic #7 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #7 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 9.0 from the White Mountain pedigree that sold for the price of $575 in December 2002. An 8.0 from the Bethlehem pedigree has an April 2004 value of $259, and an unretouched 6.5 sold for the price of $150 in October 2014, which is an increase from its April 2003 value of $62.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A miserable old man plans to mess with his nephew in Mystic #7, published by Atlas Comics in March 1952. An old man is wealthy but miserly, so to entertain himself he plots to pretend to be dead, just to squash the expectations of his nephew. However, when he tries to reveal himself, he discovers he actually died, and hes now a ghost!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $125 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $575 |
Issue #8
What's Mystic #8 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #8 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.5 that sold for the price of $1,320. That June 2019 value is a decrease from its October 2015 price of $2,041, but an increase from its May 2010 value of $260. An unretouched 5.0 has a value of $145 as of June 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man discovers how to communicate with a Sphinx in Mystic #8, published in May 1952 by Atlas Comics. A man communicates with the Sphinx's spirit, trying to learn Egypt's great secrets. The Sphinx thinks that Egypt's greatest secret is the mummification process - which it begins to demonstrate on him!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $125 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $2,041 |
Issue #9
What's Mystic #9 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #9 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 9.0 that sold for the price of $236 in July 2006. An unretouched 6.0 has an April 2018 value of $300, which is an increase from its June 2014 price of $133. An unretouched 4.5 has a value of $150 as of November 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A grave robber learns his lesson the hard way in Mystic #9, published by Atlas Comics in June 1952. Harry sees ghosts in his dreams after he robs coffins, and is afraid to go to sleep. He visits a doctor who promises a dreamless sleep, but when he takes the pill, he discovers the ghosts are real, the pill actually killed him, and the ghosts are back for revenge.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $310 |
Issue #10
What's Mystic #10 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #10 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 9.0 from the White Mountain pedigree that sold for the price of $885 in August 2012. An unretouched 7.5 has a February 2014 value of $235, and an unretouched 6.0 sold for the price of $280 in March 2020, which is an increase from its January 2016 value of $150.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A killer innkeeper pays a steep price in Mystic #10, published in July 1952 by Atlas Comics. Bluebeard robs and murders the guests that stay at his inn, and discovers a bottle of nitro in the possession of his latest victim. He decides to dispose of the bottle outside, but when he returns, all of the ghosts of his victims are able to seize him!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $375 | $1,500 | $885 |
Issue #11
What's Mystic #11 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #11 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an 8.5 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $276 in April 2004. An unretouched 8.0 has a June 2005 value of $104, and an unretouched 5.5 sold for the price of $235 in December 2017, which is an increase from its February 2014 value of $89.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A young boys toy soldiers come to life in Mystic #11, published by Atlas Comics in August 1952. Tommy Norton is playing with his small toy soldiers when his aunt comes into the room. She attempts to murder him, but his toy soldier comes to life and shoots his aunt before she can.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $70 | $140 | $275 | $550 | $2,200 | $276 |
Issue #12
What's Mystic #12 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #12 is unknown. There have been no copies to sell publicly.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A gangster always wears a mysterious hood in Mystic #12, published in September 1952 by Atlas Comics. In 'The Hooded Horror,' the leader of a gang always wears a mysterious hood that covers his face. His minions become increasingly curious about what the hood is hiding, so they use a knife on him while he's asleep to cut the hood off - just to discover the hood was his head! In 'Stop the Presses,' a reporter is driven mad by the slow news and decides to murder the paper's editor so that there can be a new sensational story.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $120 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $0 |
Issue #13
What's Mystic #13 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #13 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 8.5 that sold for the price of $462 in November 2019. An unretouched 7.0 has a November 2013 value of $294, which is a decrease from its peak December 2012 price of $398. An unretouched 2.5 sold for the price of $80 in October 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man is terrorized in the dark in Mystic #13, published by Atlas Comics in October 1952. Kurt Ravec faces his deepest nightmares in 'In The Dark.' Other stories include 'Terror on Stage' and 'The Man With the Knife!'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $275 | $525 | $2,000 | $398 |
Issue #14
What's Mystic #14 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #14 is $1,225. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 9.0 NM. That April 2018 value is an increase from its June 2005 price of $330. A 9.4 from the Bethlehem pedigree has a value of $800 as of July 2011, and an unretouched 5.0 has a value of $180 as of January 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man who isn't dead yet is mistaken by the dead as one of them in Mystic #14, published in November 1952 by Atlas Comics. In 'The Corpse and I,' haunted skeletons are dragging a man back into their lair. He screams he's still alive - but that doesn't deter them from forcing him to join them.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $90 | $180 | $350 | $1,400 | $1,225 |
Issue #15
What's Mystic #15 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #15 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 9.0 that sold for the price of $565 in November 2019. A 9.0 from the River City pedigree has an October 2002 value of $460, a 9.0 from the Davis Crippen pedigree sold for the price of $263 in November 2006, and an unretouched 6.5 has a value of $384 as of February 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A couple becomes trapped in Mystic #15, published by Atlas Comics in December 1952. A couple becomes trapped in 'House of Horror,' surrounded by the undead and monsters from their nightmares. An artist makes alternations to a matter transmitter to create things from his imagination, but more than a human is created.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $125 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $478 |
Issue #16
What's Mystic #16 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #16 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $1,555 in October 2015. An unretouched 6.5 has a value of $285 as of February 2018, an unretouched 6.0 sold for the price of $141 in November 2019, and an unretouched 4.0 has a September 2019 value of $104.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A couple is rapidly aged in Mystic #16, published in January 1953 by Atlas Comics. A young couple goes through the Tunnel of Love, but when they reach the end, they discover theyve been rapidly aged to the elderly. They attempt to go back through the tunnel, and come out at the beginning - but still at an old age.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $60 | $120 | $240 | $475 | $1,800 | $1,555 |
Issue #17
What's Mystic #17 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #17 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.5 that sold for the price of $800 in September 2016. An unretouched 6.0 has a January 2016 value of $287, and an unretouched 4.5 sold for the price of $179 in March 2018, which is a decrease from its peak August 2015 value of $359.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Vampires are running amuck in Mystic #17, published by Atlas Comics in February 1953. Teddy finds the corpse of a man that was killed by vampires. He tries to tell his parents about the body, but they dismiss him and ground him for lying. Once theyre alone, the parents reveal that they are actually the vampires - who are worried Teddy might discover their secret!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $200 | $400 | $800 | $1,600 | $6,400 | $800 |
Issue #18
What's Mystic #18 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #18 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an 8.0 from the Davis Crippen pedigree that sold for the price of $203 in November 2006. An unretouched 7.5 has a value of $2,050 in September 2019, an unretouched 7.0 sold for the price of $1,755, and an unretouched 6.5 has a value of $1,494 as of November 2014.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A lowly slave woman has big dreams in Mystic #18, published in March 1953 by Atlas Comics. A young woman was brought to Old Bagdad as a slave, but schemes to become the elderly Sultan's next wife. She succeeds, but soon learns of a horrible custom of the country - once the Sultan dies, his wife is thrown to the lions!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $375 | $725 | $1,350 | $2,500 | $10,000 | $2,390 |
Issue #19
What's Mystic #19 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #19 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $1,000. That June 2018 value is an increase from its February 2016 price of $406. An unretouched 5.0 sold for the price of $395 in May 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man quits after his boss stiffs him in Mystic #19, published by Atlas Comics in April 1953. A toy demonstrator quits his department store job after the cheap store owner gives him a Christmas bonus of only a dime. The owner tries to save money on the help wanted ad by abbreviating the sign to 'Demon. Wanted.' just to receive exactly what he asked for.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $150 | $300 | $600 | $1,200 | $4,800 | $1,000 |
Issue #20
What's Mystic #20 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #20 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $780. That June 2019 value is an increase from its July 2007 price of $131. An unretouched 7.5 has a November 2014 value of $1,016.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A witchs son because a crooked Count in Mystic #20, published in May 1953 by Atlas Comics. The Count forces his mother to use her magic to take advantage of the peasants and gain wealth for himself. When she dies, she gives him a doll that she claims is the figure of his enemy. He dies before she can tell him what to do with it, and as it has no face, he decides to burn the doll at a party with all of his enemies - just to be lit on fire himself.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $200 | $400 | $775 | $3,100 | $1,016 |
Looking to sell your comic books?
Browse our selection of key issues from Mystic below to get an instant estimate of their value.
We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!
Issue #21
What's Mystic #21 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #21 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $601 in January 2019. An unretouched 6.5 has a July 2019 value of $440, an unretouched 6.0 sold for the price of $430 in January 2016, and an unretouched 3.5 has a value of $225 as of November 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man buys a lifelike doll for his dying daughter in Mystic #21, published by Atlas Comics in July 1953. Dorothy's father is distraught that she is dying, so to cheer her up he buys her a doll that looks lifelike and similar to her. He unintentionally fools Death, who takes the doll and leaves Dorothy!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $110 | $225 | $425 | $750 | $3,000 | $657 |
Issue #22
What's Mystic #22 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #22 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 9.0 from the Davis Crippen pedigree that sold for the price of $359. That May 2010 value is an increase from its October 2006 price of $263. An unretouched 8.5 sold for the price of $501 in October 2015.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Mummies are out for revenge in Mystic #22, published in August 1953 by Atlas Comics. A man meets his match when mummies come back to life in 'Doom in the Tomb.' Other stories featured in the comic are 'Ghost Ship' and 'Man-Eater.'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $80 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $523 |
Issue #23
What's Mystic #23 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #23 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $747 in November 2014. A 7.5 from the Davis Crippen pedigree has a November 2006 value of $102, and an unretouched 7.0 sold for the price of $335 in April 2018, which is an increase from its January 2008 value of $156.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Shrunken heads are haunting Mystic #23, published by Atlas Comics in September 1953. A man travels to Jivaro so that he can obtain shrunken heads for his horror collection. He is afraid that the tribes will shrink his head, so he gets a scientist to treat his head and make it unshrinkable. A Jivaro chief captures him, and the adventurer bets that if they can't shrink his head, they'll give him an already shrunken head and he can go free. They fail to shrink his head and let him go - but they've shrunk his body instead!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $747 |
Issue #24
What's Mystic #24 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #24 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 7.5 from the Davis Crippen pedigree that sold for the price of $1,236 in October 2016. An unretouched 7.5 has a March 2015 value of $1,135, an unretouched 7.0 sold for the price of $641 in July 2019, and an unretouched 6.0 has a value of $665 as of September 2017.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Quasimodo is framed for murder in Mystic #24, published in October 1953 by Atlas Comics. Quasimodo has only one friend, and when that person is murdered by gargoyles, he is pinned for the murder and hung.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $150 | $300 | $650 | $1,300 | $5,000 | $1,236 |
Issue #25
What's Mystic #25 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #25 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.5 that sold for the price of $777 in February 2016. An unretouched 7.0 has a November 2011 value of $175, and an unretouched 6.5 sold for the price of $408 in August 2019, which is a decrease from its June 2019 price of $500.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A wife learns that what the Jones have isn't always better in Mystic #25, published by Atlas Comics in December 1953. An overbearing wife constantly nags her husband to have whatever the neighbors have, but bigger and better. One day he comes home to tell her about what the neighbor's wife just received, and she begins to bully him and demand she gets a better one. The neighbors wife got a hole in the head, so the husband picks up his shotgun.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $125 | $225 | $425 | $800 | $3,200 | $777 |
Issue #26
What's Mystic #26 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #26 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 6.5 that sold for the price of $598 in November 2014. An unretouched 6.0 has a December 2015 value of $310, and an unretouched 5.5 sold for the price of $600 in June 2019, which is an increase from its September 2017 value of $392.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Mister Smith is served a head on a platter in Mystic #26, published in January 1954 by Atlas Comics. A man's head is detached, so he decides to get revenge on the surgeon who removed it. Using hypnotic compulsion, he removes the surgeon's head and swaps it with his own.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $150 | $300 | $600 | $1,200 | $4,800 | $600 |
Issue #27
What's Mystic #27 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #27 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 6.0 that sold for the price of $277 in December 2015. An unretouched 4.0 has a July 2019 value of $240, an unretouched 3.5 sold for the price of $30 in September 2010, and an unretouched 3.5 has a value of $174 as of December 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A crew turns on their captain in Mystic #27, published by Atlas Comics in February 1954. A captain with wooden legs creates grueling conditions for the furnace stokers, working them until they drop from exhaustion. When the coal is all gone, they still are far from port, so they begin using wood to power the ship. When the wood is gone, they are just a small distance from port, so they throw the captain in the furnace to use his wooden legs to power them the rest of the way. ?
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $140 | $275 | $525 | $1,000 | $4,000 | $277 |
Issue #28
What's Mystic #28 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #28 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 6.0 that sold for the price of $1,016. That April 2016 value is an increase from its May 2015 price of $541. An unretouched 3.0 has a value of $401 as of February 2020.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Two men in the morgue are more alive than dead in Mystic #28, published in March 1954 by Atlas Comics. A decaying corpse on the coroners slab turns the tables when it turns out hes not quite dead. ?
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $250 | $500 | $1,025 | $1,900 | $7,500 | $1,016 |
Issue #29
What's Mystic #29 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #29 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $388 in July 2019. An unretouched 6.0 has a value of $114 as of December 2015, and two unretouched 5.0s sold in February 2020, one for the price of $361 and the second for $264.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man finally finds his brothers killer in Mystic #29, published by Atlas Comics in April 1954. A wife feels immense guilt, and finally reveals to her husband that she is a vampire. The husband stakes her to death, finally able to avenge the death of his brother.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $388 |
Issue #30
What's Mystic #30 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #30 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $657 in November 2014. An unretouched 6.5 has a March 2019 value of $380, and an unretouched 6.0 sold for the price of $268 in March 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A scientist moves to a small town so he can live in peace with his robot bride in Mystic #30, published in May 1954 by Atlas Comics. The inventor is a homely man, but the townspeople begin to believe the beautiful woman has been hypnotized into staying with him. When the town drunk sees him take a knife to her, they mob and lynch him, not knowing he was repairing her.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $200 | $400 | $800 | $3,200 | $657 |
Issue #31
What's Mystic #31 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #31 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 7.5 that was signed by Jack Katz that sold for the price of $300 in January 2020. An unretouched 7.0 has an October 2011 value of $80, and an unretouched 6.0 has a value of $156 as of February 2020.
Why is this comic book valuable?
The cover of Mystic #31 promises a twist you won't see coming, published by Atlas Comics in June 1954. The cover shows a man on the verge of walking off a building, touting that 'you'll never guess what this is about!!' in the main story.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $80 | $150 | $275 | $500 | $2,000 | $131 |
Issue #32
What's Mystic #32 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #32 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 6.5 that sold for the price of $438 in March 2016. An unretouched 5.0 has a November 2017 value of $227 and an unretouched 4.0 has a value of $143 as of February 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Humans face the fallout of an atomic explosion in Mystic #32, published in July 1954 by Atlas Comics. A reptilian creature stops a man from crawling to safety after an atomic explosion in 'The Survivor.' Also featured are 'A Werewolf There Was' and Rand's Ray!'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $200 | $400 | $800 | $3,200 | $438 |
Issue #33
What's Mystic #33 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #33 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $225 in December 2016. A 7.0 from the Big Apple pedigree has an April 2008 value of $92, and an unretouched 4.0 has a value of $70 as of December 2017.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man goes through his door to suddenly be above a city in Mystic #33, published by Atlas Comics in September 1954. A husband and wife discover their home has become a portal in The Unexpected. Stories from the Egyptians haunt explorers in It Happened neath the Sphinx!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $70 | $125 | $250 | $475 | $1,800 | $225 |
Issue #34
What's Mystic #34 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #34 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 7.5 that sold for the price of $347 in November 2014. An unretouched 7.0 has a September 2015 value of $495, which is an increase from its February 2008 price of $97.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man ends up in another dimension in Mystic #34, published in November 1954 by Atlas Comics. A man becomes trapped in another dimension, and while he can see his, he is trapped and cant come back. ?
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $70 | $130 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $495 |
Issue #35
What's Mystic #35 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #35 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 8.5 that sold for the price of $595 in April 2018. An unretouched 7.0 has a November 2014 value of $143, and an unretouched 3.0 has a value of $40 as of January 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man tries to kill the Devil in Mystic #35, published by Atlas Comics in January 1955. A man comes across a book that has detailed instructions for killing the Devil. He wants the fame that would come with succeeding, but once he kills the Devil, he discovers he must now take his place in Hades.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $595 |
Issue #36
What's Mystic #36 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #36 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $311 in July 2019. An unretouched 7.0 has an October 2018 value of $400, which is an increase from its November 2014 price of $203.
Why is this comic book valuable?
An alien warns of an impending invasion in Mystic #36, published in March 1955 by Atlas Comics. An alien from Jupiter has disguised himself as a human and warns humanity of an impending invasion from the people of Venus. The humans nuke the Venus aliens, giving the all-clear for the Jupiter aliens to proceed with their own invasion. ?
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $400 |
Issue #37
What's Mystic #37 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #37 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 9.2 from the River City pedigree that sold for the price of $780 in November 2019. An 8.0 from the White Mountain pedigree has a January 2007 value of $116, and an unretouched 7.5 sold for the price of $229 in June 2019, which is an increase from its February 2005 value of $65.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A florist grows majestic flowers in Mystic #37, published by Atlas Comics in March 1955. A florist grows special roses, and discovers that the flowers have become kleptomaniacs. A group of tourists in the Strange Valley come face to face with a Native god.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $80 | $160 | $300 | $1,200 | $229 |
Issue #38
What's Mystic #38 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #38 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $552. That November 2018 value is an increase from its February 2017 price of $281. An unretouched 6.5 has a value of $378 as of July 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man finds himself stuck in time in Mystic #38, published in July 1955 by Atlas Comics. Deep in winter, a man is walking outside when suddenly the world freezes at midnight. He alone is alive, walking amongst the frozen people.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $100 | $190 | $375 | $700 | $2,800 | $552 |
Issue #39
What's Mystic #39 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #39 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $108 in January 2016. An unretouched 5.5 has an October 2016 value of $117, which is an increase from its November 2014 price of $84. An unretouched 5.0 has a value of $73 as of January 2013.
Why is this comic book valuable?
An investigator follows a series of mysteriously footsteps in Mystic #39, published by Atlas Comics in September 1955. A detective sees footprints suddenly appear, and follows the 21 footsteps, trying to uncover their origin. ?
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $40 | $80 | $150 | $300 | $1,200 | $117 |
Issue #40
What's Mystic #40 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #40 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 8.0 that sold for the price of $143 in August 2008. An unretouched 6.0 has an October 2017 value of $155, and an unretouched 1.8 has a value of $19 as of November 2012.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man does impossible feats in Mystic #40, published in October 1955 by Atlas Comics. A man is dubbed "The Impossible Man" when he conducts a series of incredible tricks. A boy goes on a special holiday to the moon.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $454 |
Looking to sell your comic books?
Browse our selection of key issues from Mystic below to get an instant estimate of their value.
We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!
Issue #41
What's Mystic #41 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #41 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.5 that sold for the price of $181 in October 2018. An unretouched 7.0 has a November 2018 value of $330, which is an increase from its November 2014 price of $120. An unretouched 6.0 has a value of $179 as of November 2015.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Hamsters become intelligent masterminds in Mystic #41, published by Atlas Comics in November 1955. A psychologist has been conducting experimental tests on hamsters. One day he has a dream where they become intelligent, escape their cages, and subject him to the same electric shocks he used on them. When he wakes up, he decides to terminate his experiment and gives the hamsters away.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $330 |
Issue #42
What's Mystic #42 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #42 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 4.5 that sold for the price of $76 in August 2015. That copy is the only one to be sold at auction.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Two men attempt to hide from time itself in Mystic #42, published in December 1955 by Atlas Comics. Two men cower inside the house, trying to hide from 'At the Stroke of Midnight.' Other stories include 'Ho-Ji' and 'One Who Lived.'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $75 | $150 | $300 | $600 | $2,400 | $76 |
Issue #43
What's Mystic #43 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #43 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 8.0 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $124 in August 2010. An unretouched 6.5 has a November 2014 value of $96, and an unretouched 5.5 sold for the price of $51 in February 2016, which is a decrease from its peak March 2014 price of $166.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A bookkeeper dreams he's a secret agent in Mystic #43, published by Atlas Comics in January 1956. A bookkeeper is bored with his life, so begins to dream that he has become a spy. His mission is to hunt a mad scientist who is threatening the world with his destructive sound device.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | $70 | $125 | $250 | $1,000 | $168 |
Issue #44
What's Mystic #44 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #44 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 6.5 that sold for the price of $108 in November 2014. The only other copy of #44 to sell publicly is an unretouched 5.5 that has a November 2012 value of $82.
Why is this comic book valuable?
An alien from Venus is kidnapping humans in Mystic #44, published in April 1956 by Atlas Comics. An alien woman from Venus is trying to save her dying world. She begins to kidnap humans to help repopulate her world. When Saturn broadcasts a movie, a human mistakes it for an invasion plan and tells everyone that Earth is about to be invaded.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $108 |
Issue #45
What's Mystic #45 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #45 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $144 in October 2018. An unretouched 6.5 has a November 2014 value of $388.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Deep-sea creatures rise to the surface in Mystic #45, published by Atlas Comics in March 1956. Humanity is faced with creatures from their nightmares in 'When the Ocean Vanished.' Other stories include 'The Extra Sense' and 'A Trip to the Moon.'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $90 | $180 | $350 | $1,400 | $388 |
Issue #46
What's Mystic #46 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #46 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is also the only copy to sell at auction. That copy is a 7.0 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $79 in July 2009. That value is a decrease from its September 2004 price of $93.
Why is this comic book valuable?
There are three stories steeped in mystery featured on the cover of Mystic #46, published in April 1956 by Atlas Comics. The first is 'The Key That Lived,' where an ordinary keep becomes haunted. In 'The Man Who Found Himself,' a man's ghost is finally reunited with his body. Two men are confronted with 'The Mysterious Stranger.'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $90 |
Issue #47
What's Mystic #47 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #47 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.5 that sold for the price of $345 in March 2013. An unretouched 4.5 that has been signed by Stan Lee has a February 2017 value of $200.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man discovers he can do anything in Mystic #47, published by Atlas Comics in May 1956. In 'Patent Pending,' a brilliant teen invents a mechanical potato peeler. However, a supernatural figure suddenly appears to stop him, as it wants to preserve the culture of hand-peeling potatoes.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $110 | $225 | $450 | $1,800 | $345 |
Issue #48
What's Mystic #48 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #48 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 9.0 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $180 in October 2005. An unretouched 5.0 has a value of $62 as of November 2015.
Why is this comic book valuable?
An alien from Mercury takes revenge on a greedy human in Mystic #48, published in June 1956 by Atlas Comics. An alien from Mercury is in disguise as a human, but changes into his real form at midnight. When a crooked man tries to turn him in for reward money, the Mercurian kidnaps him and takes him back to his own planet to teach him a lesson.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $90 | $175 | $350 | $1,400 | $180 |
Issue #49
What's Mystic #49 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #49 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 5.5 that sold for the price of $110 in July 2018. An unretouched 1.0 that has been signed by editor Stan Lee has an October 2003 value of $17.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man is haunted by unseeable creatures in Mystic #49, published by Atlas Comics in July 1956. A man tries telling everyone else of the threat of a mysterious creature that only he can see, but no one believes him.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | $70 | $125 | $250 | $1,000 | $110 |
Issue #50
What's Mystic #50 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #50 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an 8.0 from the White Mountain pedigree that sold for the price of $127 in March 2003. An unretouched 6.0 has a November 2015 value of $179, and an unretouched 3.5 sold for the price of $44 in May 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A child does everything backward in Mystic #50, published in August 1956 by Atlas Comics. A young boy is excelling in sports and school, but puzzles the world as he does everything backwards.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $65 | $125 | $250 | $500 | $2,000 | $179 |
Issue #51
What's Mystic #51 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #51 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is also the only copy to sell publicly, which is an unretouched 5.5 that sold for the price of $179 in November 2015.
Why is this comic book valuable?
An adventurer discovers a city made of gold in Mystic #51, published by Atlas Comics in September 1956. An explorer finds a city hidden deep in the jungle, and the entire city is made of gold. He takes part of it and returns to civilization, just to discover it is actually fools gold. He doesnt realize that the large field he crossed to get to the city was actually a diamond field.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $110 | $225 | $450 | $1,800 | $179 |
Issue #52
What's Mystic #52 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #52 is $250. This value is based on the highest-rated copy to sell publicly, which is a 9.4 NM from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold in January 2007. There have been two copies that have been modified by restoration artists.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A criminal finds a way around punishment in Mystic #52, published in October 1956 by Atlas Comics. A crook steals an effigy from a cult that practices voodoo. They created it to make him surrender himself to the authorities, but he uses it to escape the police.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $30 | $60 | $120 | $240 | $950 | $0 |
Issue #53
What's Mystic #53 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #53 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 7.0 that sold for the price of $300 in February 2018. An unretouched 6.5 has a March 2014 value of $87, and an unretouched 5.0 has a value of $168 as of September 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man tells his brother he is in possession of a great treasure in Mystic #53, published by Atlas Comics in November 1956. The man tells his brother he has hidden his riches in a locked trunk, and the trunk will pass to the brother if he stays with the man. The brother is overcome with curiosity, and one day steals the key. He discovers the trunk is actually a portal to another world, and sees a girl who is also trapped by her sibling. They leave the trunk and escape together.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $50 | $100 | $200 | $400 | $1,600 | $300 |
Issue #54
What's Mystic #54 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #54 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 9.0 that sold for the price of $446 in July 2019. An unretouched 8.5 sold for the price of $446 in march 2015, which is an increase from its March 2006 value of $136.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man suddenly develops the power to read minds in Mystic #54, published in December 1956 by Atlas Comics. A man visits a volcano and suddenly gains the power to read minds from the vapors. He uses his newfound power to achieve great political power.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $90 | $175 | $350 | $1,400 | $446 |
Issue #55
What's Mystic #55 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #55 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 9.2 that sold for the price of $320 in November 2012. A 9.0 from the Circle 8 pedigree has a March 2008 value of $100, and an unretouched 8.0 from the same pedigree has a value of $78 as of May 2009.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A man tries to go back in time and usurp Arthur in Mystic #55, published by Atlas Comics in January 1957. A man goes back in time to try to kill King Arthur and make himself king. He doesn't know how to craft metal and chemistry to build weapons, so instead he becomes Arthur's personal sorcerer - Merlin.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $40 | $80 | $160 | $325 | $1,200 | $320 |
Issue #56
What's Mystic #56 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #56 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is an unretouched 5.5 that sold for the price of $26 in August 2004. That copy is the only copy to sell at auction.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Horrific creatures rise from the underground while the city sleeps in Mystic #56, published in February 1957 by Atlas Comics. At night, molemen rise from beneath San Francisco, wanting to take revenge on the surface-dwellers and retake the world. An earthquake happens because of the molemen's tunneling, setting the city on fire, which prompts the molemen to return to their caves.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | $65 | $125 | $250 | $1,000 | $26 |
Issue #57
What's Mystic #57 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #57 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is a 9.0 from the White Mountain pedigree that sold for the price of $1,249. That July 2018 value is an increase from its February 2016 price of $895. An unretouched 8.0 has a value of $284 as of November 2012.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A scientist becomes trapped by ants in Mystic #57, published by Atlas Comics in March 1957. Dr. Perry Moore creates a serum that allows him to shrink dramatically, but once time that he shrinks he becomes trapped within an ant hill.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $65 | $125 | $225 | $400 | $1,600 | $1,249 |
Issue #58
What's Mystic #58 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #58 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 9.0 from the Circle 8 pedigree that sold for the price of $350 in March 2013. An 8.5 from the Bethlehem pedigree has an April 2009 value of $165, and an unretouched 6.5 sold for the price of $84 in November 2015.
Why is this comic book valuable?
People suddenly vanish in Mystic #58, published in April 1957 by Atlas Comics. Dark secrets lie behind the mystery of 'Those Who Vanished.' You dont want to miss the story of 'The Day The World Ended.'
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $35 | $65 | $125 | $250 | $1,000 | $350 |
Issue #59
What's Mystic #59 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #59 is $329. That value is based on the highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction, which is a 9.4 NM from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold in February 2006. A 9.0 from the Circle 8 pedigree has a February 2018 value of $399, and an unretouched 8.0 sold for the price of $300 in July 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Aliens come to the planet in Mystic #59, published by Atlas Comics in May 1957. On a dark and stormy night, alien invaders attack an ocean liner. The aliens are disguised as a storm cloud, but when a real hurricane approaches, the aliens are engulfed and sink into the ocean.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $45 | $90 | $175 | $350 | $1,400 | $415 |
Issue #60
What's Mystic #60 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #60 is unknown. The highest-rated copy to sell publicly is a 9.2 from the Bethlehem pedigree that sold for the price of $345 in August 2004. An unretouched 9.0 has a July 2011 value of $150, and an unretouched 5.0 has a value of $200 as of October 2018.
Why is this comic book valuable?
A criminal meets justice in an unlikely way in Mystic #60, published in June 1957 by Atlas Comics. A crook is on the run from authorities and decides to hole up in a relatives house to lay low. One day he goes to the swimming hole and tries to scare away the children there, but they turn out to be gremlins who take him to their lair.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $55 | $110 | $225 | $450 | $1,800 | $345 |
Looking to sell your comic books?
Browse our selection of key issues from Mystic below to get an instant estimate of their value.
We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!
Issue #61
What's Mystic #61 worth in 2024?
The mint condition value of Mystic #61 is unknown. The highest CGC rated copy to sell at auction is an unretouched 6.0 that has a March 2020 value of $325. That price is an increase from its August 2012 value of $78 and October 2011 value of $56.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Mystic #61 is the final issue of the series, and was published by Atlas Comics in August 1957. The cover story is 'The Thirteenth Floor, where a hotel employee is the only person able to see the ghosts that haunt the 13th floor. He meets an untimely death when he attempts to steal the ghost's riches, plummeting to his doom in the elevator shaft.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $40 | $75 | $150 | $300 | $1,200 | $78 |