Disclaimer:
When you click on link title "Check Live eBay Prices Here" on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include the eBay Partner Network. Check our Privacy Policy for more information.
Amazing Mysteries
Marvel // May 1949 - January 1950
Issue count: 4
The last issue of the true crime stories, the Amazing Mysteries series!
Atlas grew out of Timely Comics, the publisher that first brought The Human Torch, Sub-Mariner and Captain America in the 1940’s. But by 1950, the superhero stories were old-fashioned and TV and books were competing for the audience’s attention.
The villains featured in The Human Torch, Captain America and Sub-Mariner stories were all too similar and the comics broke no ground, leading to the cancellation of Captain America and the rebranding of Sub-Mariner Comics to Amazing Mysteries, where they started experimenting with different genres such as western, humor or crime/horror.
However, Amazing Mysteries wasn't that famous either and it only ran for 4 issues before being cancelled.
Follow Quality Comix’s links in the online price guide to see the prices that some of these issues are currently fetching on the collectors market!
Looking to sell your comic books?
Browse our selection of key issues from Amazing Mysteries below to get an instant estimate of their value.
We have been buying and selling for 20 years and have tons of experience working with sellers just like you!
Issue #32
What's Amazing Mysteries #32 worth in 2024?
The highest recorded sale of issue 32 in existence (or once on the market) has a 9.0 CGC VF/NM and sold for the price of $1,315 in 2006. A lower grade copy of this issue in the 2.0 CGC GD mark sold for $287 in 2015, so good luck finding this issue (that doesn't cost you a few hundred bucks.)
Why is this comic book valuable?
You'll encounter terrifying tales such as The Thing at Chugamung Cove, The Menace from the Past, The Isle of No Return, and A Letter to Our Our Readers and Their Parents in this issue of Amazing Mysteries!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $290 | $470 | $925 | $1,675 | $5,200 | $1,675 |
Issue #33
What's Amazing Mysteries #33 worth in 2024?
The highest recorded sale of issue 33 in existence (or once on the market) has a 8.5 CGC NM and sold for the price of $371 in 2019. A lower grade copy of this issue in the 2.0 CGC GD mark sold for $106 in 2019, so attaining such a rarity won't leave a crater in your wallet.
Why is this comic book valuable?
The Thing in the Vault!, A Letter to Our Readers and Their Parents, Terror in the Tomb!, A Moment of Horror, and The Monster that Prowled! are all crammed into this issue.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $110 | $170 | $410 | $1,000 | $3,600 | $500 |
Issue #34
What's Amazing Mysteries #34 worth in 2024?
Issue 34 of Amazing Mysteries does not appear on the CGC registry, but it I rumoured to go for a $300 value if its condition has little to no wear in 2019.
Why is this comic book valuable?
In issue number 34 of Amazing Mysteries, you'll encounter terrifying tales such as Poppy Chavez, The Strange Woman!, The Kissing Buccaneer, The Rivals, and My Fatal Mistake!
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | $40 | $80 | $160 | $500 | $0 |
Issue #35
What's Amazing Mysteries #35 worth in 2024?
The highest recorded sale of issue 35 in existence (or once on the market) has a 6.5 CGC NM and sold for the price of $139 in 2017. This was the only sale listed in the CGC registry, so finding this rarity may be incredibly difficult.
Why is this comic book valuable?
Issue 35 of Amazing Mysteries features terrifying tales such as Danny Guild/The Hood from Hell's Kitchen, The Highway of Doom!, Decoy for the Hot Seat, and Professor M. Vargas/The Terror of Budapest.
Price Guide Report
| GD 2.0 | VG 4.0 | FN 6.0 | VF 8.0 | NM 9.4 | RECORD SALE! |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| $20 | $40 | $80 | $160 | $500 | $140 |